Poor Performance Dismissals

Poor Performance Dismissals – How to Dismiss Under-performers the Right Way.

Dismissing an employee for underperformance in South Africa requires following a specific process to ensure it’s legal and fair. Here’s a simplified overview, but remember it’s crucial to consult with a qualified labour law professional for specific guidance:

Establishing Fair Grounds:
  • Performance standards: Ensure clear, documented job descriptions outlining performance expectations.
  • Evidence of underperformance: Gather objective evidence demonstrating the employee’s consistent failure to meet these standards.
Following Fair Procedures:
  • Informal counseling: Discuss the performance issues with the employee, understand their perspective, and explore potential reasons for underperformance.
  • Performance improvement plan (PIP): If improvement is possible, implement a formal PIP with clear goals, timelines, and support offered by the employer.
  • Monitoring and evaluation: Regularly track the employee’s progress against the PIP and provide feedback.
  • Incapacity enquiry: If performance doesn’t improve after the PIP, initiate aincapacity enquiry following proper procedures, allowing the employee an opportunity to be heard on their constant under performance.  This can be done in the form of a documented discussion or a more formal enquiry.
Considering Alternatives:
  • Training and development: Explore if additional training or development opportunities can address the performance gaps.
  • Alternative placement: Consider transferring the employee to a more suitable role if possible.
  • Demotion: Explore whether a demoted position is available.  If so, a salary decrease or salary freeze should be imposed.
Dismissal as a Last Resort:
  • If all efforts to improve performance fail, and dismissal seems unavoidable, ensure the decision is based on a fair and thorough process documented with evidence.
Additional Points to Remember:
  • Seek legal advice: Consulting a labour law professional throughout the process is crucial to ensure compliance with legal requirements and minimize the risk of legal challenges.
  • South African Labour Law: Familiarize yourself with relevant South African Labour Law, including the Labour Relations Act (LRA) and relevant case law, for a deeper understanding of your rights and obligations as an employer.

Remember, this is a simplified outline, and the specific steps involved can vary depending on the circumstances. It’s essential to seek professional guidance from a qualified labour law practitioner, such as Kirchmanns Inc., to navigate the complexities of employee dismissal legally and fairly in South Africa. Contact us here, we can help.

Read more articles here or Visit us on Facebook